Comparative Analysis Of Humanization Present In Nursing Assistance Between Brazil And New York: A Lived Experience

  • Bianka Pereira Evangelista
  • Elicarlos Marques Nunes Faculdades Integradas de Patos, Paraíba, Brasil
  • Ana Paula Suassuna Veras Barreto
  • Andréia Rayanne Queroz de Sousa
  • Francisca Lima dos Santos
  • Jordeyanne Ferreira de Oliveira
  • Karine Lucena Alves
  • Mariana Brilhante de Lima
  • Tariana Rodrigues Nogueira
  • Juliane de Oliveira Costa Nobre
  • Edmara da Nóbrega Xavier Martins
  • Ana Beatriz Alves Barbosa
  • Kamila Nethielly Souza Leite
  • Sheila da Costa Rodrigues Silva
  • Allan Martins Ferreira


Objetive: The study is an experience report, with the objective of reporting differences in the humanization present in nursing care between a Brazilian city and two cities of the United States of America, highlighting the potentialities and fragility of care provided in both cities frequented by students of Patos Integrated College - FIP.

Method: The study was based on the exchange linked to the Bounce project, funded by the US government, which took place between May 21 and June 20, 2015, and was attended by 8 (eight) FIP scholars from Paraíba, Brazil. Through the study it was possible to perform a comparative analysis between the Brazilian hospital reality, seen in the FIP curriculum internship field, through the Deputy Janduhy Carneiro Regional Hospital, located in the municipality of Patos - Paraíba, Brazil, and the North American, evidenced by the visit to the hospitals of Hudson and New Paltz.

Results: It was observed that the difference in care is in the humanization present in the Brazilian nursing care process. It is noteworthy the great work done by these professionals, who are not only concerned with technical-scientific efficiency, but with humanized assistance, based on ethical, moral, affection and for mutual respect precepts. Comparing the assistance provided in the two realities, we observed in our country a predominantly humanistic, rather than mechanical, assistance. Therefore, it is concluded that it is fundamental to seek tools that improve our Health System, consequently, providing benefits both for professionals, as well as for the users assisted.

Conclusion: In this way, it can be said that humanization does not depend only on technological resources to be shared.

Keywords: Nursing care. Humanization. Hospital.

Author Biography

Elicarlos Marques Nunes, Faculdades Integradas de Patos, Paraíba, Brasil

Nurse. Master in Public Health. Assistance in Emergency Mobile Service and Teacher of Nursing and Public Health.

How to Cite
EVANGELISTA, Bianka Pereira et al. Comparative Analysis Of Humanization Present In Nursing Assistance Between Brazil And New York: A Lived Experience. International Archives of Medicine, [S.l.], v. 10, apr. 2017. ISSN 1755-7682. Available at: <>. Date accessed: 19 oct. 2019. doi:

Most read articles by the same author(s)